The Project:
The 45 Oak Street, Douglas solar project is one of 5 solar projects of BlueWave, a Boston-based company owned by a Canadian firm, Axium Infrastructure, which raised $91 million in equity and debt to finance five agrivoltaic projects across Massachusetts.
BlueWave secured approval in 2020 for a 3.5 MW array on approximately 20-25 acres at 45 Oak St in Douglas. Construction is to be conducted in three phases with an expected finish before the end of 2023. The BlueWave site has a dual-use goal of supplying solar energy and as an agricultural operation of sheep, goat or crop farming under the solar arrays.
With entrance at 45 Oak St. Douglas, the site straddles the Manchaug Pond Watershed at the north side of the property, Stevens Pond Watershed and Whitins Reservoir Watershed to the south.Worcester Business Journal Article. September 15, 2023
BlueWave Solar Construction Site, 45 Oak St, Douglas with Manchaug Pond in distance. 2024, February 24 (Photo by recreational drone flyer High Octane Image-High Performance
Report Environmental Impacts! Sediment Runoff, Pumping Discharge, Excessive Noise, Accidents, etc to:
Town of Douglas: Community Development Director Matt Benoit 508-476-4000 xt. 206 or mbenoit@douglas-ma.gov, Conservation Agent Brandon Faneuf bfaneuf@douglas-ma.gov
Town of Sutton Conservation Commission: 508-865-8728 Secretary Wanda Bien or Conservation Agent Brandon Faneuf bfaneuf@ecosystem-solutions.com
Town of Sutton Health Dept./Board of Health: 508-865-8724
MassDEP Wetlands: Thomas Rebula Thomas.Rebula@mass.gov
Town of Douglas Links:
Community Calendar of Meetings & Events
Douglas YouTube
Board of Selectman
Conservation Commission
Planning Board
TV Channel 192 Charter Spectrum: GOVERNMENT
Town of Sutton Links:
Community Calendar of Events
Health Department/Board of Health
Conservation Commission
Select Board
Sutton Cable: Verizon 31 & Spectrum 191
Sutton YouTube
Manchaug Pond Watershed Map
The Documents
Enforcement Order
Town of Sutton
Enforcement Order
Town of Douglas
Recent SITE INSPECTION REPORTS Peer Review/Town of Douglas
Construction Monitoring 45 Oak Street Report 2024.03.08
Construction Monitoring 45 Oak Street Report 2024.02.28
Construction Monitoring 45 Oak Street Report 2024.02.21
Construction Monitoring 45 Oak Street Report 2023.12.11
Douglas 45 Oak Monitoring Report #11
Douglas 45 Oak Monitoring Report #10
Truck Traffic/Material Trucked in:
between 5/2023 to 1/23/2024 -514 loads and 13,031.99 tons
BlueWave On-site Testing Results
PFAS Chemical Testing Results: 6 out of 40 found at Basin 5 construction site PFAS Testing Results_45 Oak Street_3-5-24 (1)
Soil Testing Results: Table 1 - Surficial Soil Analytical Results 2024.01.15
Required Restoration of impacted areas to be completed by BlueWave Solar
3/11/24 Diver activity from dam to ramp area only- No report received
As of March 22, 2024 ~ World Water Day
- No water quality testing and monitoring: ecoli, turbidity, total phosphorus, DO, etc.
- No sediment removal from Manchaug Pond, Stevens Pond or the Mumford River
- No restoration of wetland which was improved by Manchaug Pond Foundation s319 NPS Pollution Grant
- No cleaning of debris from roadsides or catch basins nor reimbursement to the Town of Douglas for cleaning, modification and repair.
- No sediment removal from neighbors forested land and wetlands property owner yet to be contacted for permission to inspect
- No follow-up PFAS testing of impacted waters and fish
What People Are Saying ~ TESTIMONY SUBMITTED
Adam, Kautza, Coldwater Fisheries Project Leader, Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife, January 19, 2024, UNT Coldwater Fishery to Manchaug Pond, Douglas.
Senator Ryan Fattman & Rep. Joseph McKenna to Douglas Board of Selectman Chair Kevin Morse and Sutton Select Board Chair Jonathan Anderson, February 21, 2024, BlueWave Solar and The Douglas and Sutton Conservation Commissions.
The Construction Site Problems:
- Cutting of the forested acreage of the 20+ acre site
- Incomplete and unstabilized phases of construction
- Removal of topsoil exposing subsoils of clay and hardpan
- Trucking in over 13,000 tons of additional clay, silt, stone, and riprap
- Repeated failure of erosion control measures resulting in numerous and repeated sediment, runoff, and erosion events of sediment and sediment-laden water discharge into abutting properties, the Oak Street neighborhood, and wetlands on Holt and Torrey Roads, Sutton, Manchaug Pond, Stevens Pond and the Mumford River and into the Whitins Reservoir watershed.
- Design failure of the three partially constructed infiltration basins resulting in regular pumping of collected sediment-laden water of basins 1, 2, and 5 with discharge onto abutting properties. Pumping results in sediment runoff and significant discharged to Oak Street, Douglas and Torrey Rd, Sutton in Manchaug Pond watershed and drying of wetlands in Stevens Pond watershed.
The Environmental Impact:
OFFSITE EROSION, SEDIMENT, RUNOFF, FILLING WETLANDS, & PUMPING DISCHARGE
December 18, 2024 Sediment runoff into Manchaug Pond from BlueWave Solar Construction Site
December 18, 2024 Sediment runoff into Manchaug Pond from BlueWave Solar Construction Site
January 10th: Turbity curtain ineffective as not installed/anchored or cleaned/maintained. Manchaug Pond southeast cove as 45 Oak St Solar site Infiltration Basin 5 failure results in significant runoff, erosion and sediment-laden water flooding Holt Rd wetland, Holt Rd and lake.
Oak St Solar Entrance January 26, 2024
BlueWave Solar Construction Sediment Runoff in Manchaug Pond 2024-Jan13
IMPACT AREA:
July 2023 to April
- Oak St., Douglas
- Holt Rd., Sutton
- Parker Ct., Douglas
- Wetlands, Holt Road, Sutton
- Manchaug Pond, Sutton/Douglas
- Stevens Pond, Sutton
- Mumford River, Manchaug
- Private Properties on Oak Street, Douglas
- Private Properties on Torrey Rd, Sutton
- Manchaug Pond watershed
- Stevens Pond watershed.
January 13th Pumping discharge from failed Infiltration Basin 2 dumping sediment-laden water through neighbor's property to Oak Street
Pumping Sediment-Laden Water Off-site to Abutters: Ongoing
- Ongoing pumping of sediment-laden water from failed infiltration basins offsite to neighborhood yards, driveways and roadsides causing flooding, erosions and washouts.
- Entrance driveway runoff of sediment-laden water flowing across and down Oak St and to Holt Road Sutton and beyond to Parker Ct, Douglas. Required cleaning of 4 catch basins, addition of berm at lower catch basin, and patching of road to handle the increase flow.
- Oak St flowing southwest towards the coldwater fishery stream and northeast downhill toward coldwater fishery stream and Manchaug Pond
- Pumping to the east to abutting properties on Torrey Rd.
May 2024
April 2024
April 12
April
MARCH 2024
March 29
March 23
March 3
JANUARY 2024
January 12 & 13:
- Light rainfall resulted in sediment-laden water flowing offsite down to Holt Rd wetlands, Manchaug Pond, Stevens Pond and Mumford
- Pumping of basin 5 resulted in sediment-laden water discharged to 78 Torrey Rd (see Facebook video)
January 10, 2024
- Light rainfall resulted in sediment-laden water to Holt Rd wetlands, Manchaug Pond, Stevens Pond and Mumford
DECEMBER 2023
December 22, 2023 at 10:00 a.m. Mumford River, Sutton below Stevens Pond Dam. Sediment and Sediment-laden water Runoff/erosion in to Manchaug Pond flowing to Stevens Pond and greater Mumford River from Bluewave Solar 45 Oak Street, Douglas Solar Construction Site.
December 21, 2023
- Town of Douglas Highway Dept. removes 5 ton of sediment from 4 Oak St Catch Basins as requested by the Conservation Commission. Total $796.32.
December 22, 2023:
- Sediment-laden waters flowing from Manchaug Pond, Stevens Pond and after the Stevens Dam in the greater Mumford River
December 18, 2023:
- Continued failure of Infiltration Basin 5 area/NW corner with significant sediment and sediment-laden waters discharged into abutting woods flowing 1300 feet down to Holt Rd, Sutton wetlands, south eastern area of Manchaug Pond from causeway to dam, Stevens Pond and Mumford River
- Continued pumping of Infiltration Basin 2 into silt-sack discharging sediment-laden water to BVW, swale, 41-45 Oak St, 42 Oak to woods behind house, down Oak St to Holt Road Sutton to Parker Ct. Douglas
- Runoff from site entrance down Oak St to Holt Rd Sutton and to Parker Rd, Douglas
December 11, 2023:
- Failure of Infiltration Basin 5 at northeast corner of site resulting in overtopping with significant erosion of clay and silt resulting in sediment-laden waters flowing 1,300 feet off site to abutters woods, downn 200 ft elevation to wetlands and Holt Rd, Sutton, and Manchaug Pond from dam to causeway. Flow out dam carried to Stevens Pond and greater Mumford River
- Infiltration Basin 2 pumped into silt-sack discharging sediment-laden water to bordering vetetated wetlands, swale, 41-45 Oak St, 42 Oak to woods behind house, down Oak St to Holt Road Sutton to Parker Ct. Douglas (see Facebook for videos and photos)
Enforcement Action by Towns
Douglas Conservation Commission, Planning Board and the Board of Selectman took action with Enforcement Order and call for redesigns of failed Infiltration Basins 1, 2 and 5.
April 1, 2024: DOUGLAS CONSERVATION COMMISSION Votes 3 to 1
March 20, 2024: SUTTON CONSERVATION COMMISSION Votes
January 2024: DOUGLAS Planning Board
January 12, 2024: DOUGLAS CONSERVATION COMMISSION Request
January 8, 2024: Enforcement order Issued by DOUGLAS CONSERVATION COMMISSION
January 3, 2024: Restoration Plan V.3 submitted to Sutton/Douglas CONSERVATION
- Documents December 10 and 11th sedimentation events and December 27-28 failure of Infiltration Basin #5 by overtopping, failure of sediment/erosion control barriers
- Identifies 45 Oak St, Douglas and 25R Holt Road, Sutton as "Heavy Impact" with other parcels and water resources as only "possible impact"
- Proposed Restoration Plan
- Pre-Restoration
- Soil Deposition Removal with the Upland, Wetland and Intermittent Stream
- Sediment Removal Within Manchaug Pond
December 20, 2023: Enforcement Order Issued by Sutton Conservation Commission
- “Shall immediately cease and desist from any activity affecting the Buffer Zone and/or resource areas.
- Resource area alterations resulting from said activity shall be corrected and the resource areas returned to their original condition
- A restoration plan shall be filed with the issuing authority on or before 1/2/2024”
In Jeopardy:
Coldwater Fishery & Manchaug Pond's Southwest Cove:
- a woodland stream on private lands is habitat for native Eastern Brook Trout and brings fresh water to Manchaug Pond's southwest cove.
LETTER: Adam, Kautza, Coldwater Fisheries Project Leader, Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife, January 19, 2024, UNT Coldwater Fishery to Manchaug Pond, Douglas.
Manchaug Pond Foundation has testified to both towns the urgency, arranged a site visit with the Conservation agent, staff and a Sutton Conservation Commissioner participating, and has secured a follow-up survey of the stream by MassWildlife to access it's health for summer 2024.
More on the subject of solar, climate, and protecting our natural resources...
BMPs for Solar Installations - Preserving Nature, Forests & Farmland
Growing Solar, Protecting Nature. Massachusetts Audubon and Harvard Forest, October 2023.
Large-Scale Solar Installations Position Paper and Resource Guide for Town Officials. Blackstone River Watershed Association, October 9, 2018.
Coldwater Fisheries
Mass Fisheries and Wildlife. Coldwater Fish Resources.
Russ Cohen, Rivers Advocate. Mass Dept of Fish and Game, Division of Ecological Restoration. 10 Ways Conservation Commissions And Others Can Protect Coldwater Streams and Their Inhabitants. Sea Run Brook Trout Coalition. July 10, 2017.
Glen Krevousky & Russ Cohen. EBT Environmental, Inc. Additional Opportunities to Protect Trout Streams in the Commonwealth. Website Page
Jason Dunham, US Forest Service. Chapter 8. Coldwater Fish in Wadeable Streams. 2009.
The "Forever Chemicals" - PFAS
Mass Department of Energy and Enviromental Affairs Data Portal. State testing in 2022 of public water supplies found NO PFAS at Manchaug Pond campgrounds
Mass Dept of Environmental Affairs. Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS)
Mass Dept. of Public Health. PFAS Fish and Surface Water Surveillance
Various PFAS Presentations & Webinars on YouTube.
Mass Department of Environmental Protection (MassDEP), Www.youtube.com/@MassDEP.
What are PFAS? Waterkeeepers Alliance website.
...most importantly, cutting forests and developing farmlands to build solar energy doesn’t make sense for the climate: natural ecosystems and farm soils absorb 10% of Massachusetts’ greenhouse gas emissions every year.
Comments 1
Blue Wave proposed an equally poorly conceived and designed project for Belchertown – a large array situated in steeply forested bedrock slopes. The obvious threat of flooding and ersoion was initially dismissed with a solution to plant ‘meadow mix’. After strong criticism, the plans progressed to some shallow catchment pools, and finally wound up with a proposal for a large containment pond held back by an unstable dam design, perched on an eroding cliff adjacent to a small home. It took two and one half years for residents, meeting bi-monthly, reviewing adjustments to the design, and responding with research, to convince the Planning Board that it would be in the town’s best interests to deny a permit. In our view, the company routinely presented plans based on incorrect or incomplete data, and submitted new or redeisgned plans at the last minute, with changes based on achieving the appearance of desired outcomes (largely through questionable analyses and inaccurate use of geological information) rather than actually redesigning the project. The letter from Sen Ryan Fattman & Rep. Joseph McKenna describes the inadequate response of the company to date as bubble gum and duct tape, which also describes their design practice. It is hard to understand why they are licensed in the Commonwealth.